Harmonious Construction or Judicial Disobedience of Stare Decisis? Suraini Kempe & Ors v Kerajaan Malaysia & Ors

Main Article Content

Mohamad Hafiz Hassan

Abstract

In Suraini Kempe & Ors v Kerajaan Malaysia & Ors, the High Court ruled, on a harmonious construction of the relevant constitutional provisions on citizenship and equality before the law, the word ‘father’ in Article 14(1)(b), read together with section 1(c) of Part II of the Second Schedule of the Federal Constitution includes the mother of the children born out of Malaysia, and therefore declared, among others, that children born out of Malaysia, to mothers who are Malaysian citizens, are entitled to citizenship by operation of law if all the procedures to those followed by the father are adhered to. A harmonious construction is one where two provisions of the Constitution bearing upon the same subject are read together and so interpreted as to give meaning and effect to, and not render, the provision of the Constitution as otiose or nugatory. Curiously, the learned judge avoided referring to a recent Federal Court decision which ruled there was no necessity to adopt any other requirement to construe the constitutional provisions. The decision, albeit by a majority, is binding on the learned judge. This case comment argues that the learned judge disregarded and disobeyed the well-entrenched doctrine of stare decisis.

Article Details

How to Cite
Hassan, M. H. (2022). Harmonious Construction or Judicial Disobedience of Stare Decisis? Suraini Kempe & Ors v Kerajaan Malaysia & Ors. Asian Journal of Law and Policy, 2(1), 15–31. https://doi.org/10.33093/ajlp.2022.2
Section
Case Commentaries

References

'114 Organisations and 52 Individuals, 'Ending gender bias in conferring citizenship' The Star (14 September 2021) <https://www.thestar.com.my/opinion/letters/2021/09/14/ending-gender-bias-in-conferring-citizenship>.

Ashley Tang, 'Rina Harun welcomes High Court citizenship decision, says sheds new light on aspirations of women' The Star (11 September 2021) <https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2021/09/11/rina-harun-welcomes-high-court-citizenship-decision-says-sheds-new-light-on-aspirations-of-women>.

S Indramalar, 'Citizenship rights: One giant step forward for gender-equal laws' The Star (9 September 2021) <https://www.thestar.com.my/lifestyle/family/2021/09/09/a-women039s-right-high-court-decision-is-on-giant-step-forward-for-gender-equal-laws>.

S Indramalar, 'Justice delayed is justice denied, group says' The Star (14 September 2021) <https://www.thestar.com.my/lifestyle/family/2021/09/14/justice-delayed-is-justice-denied-group-says>.

See Heng Seai Kie, 'Wanita MCA urges govt to heed public opinion to uphold High Court ruling, promote gender equality in Malaysia' The Star (13 September 2021) <https://www.thestar.com.my/opinion/letters/2021/09/13/wanita-mca-urges-govt-to-heed-public-opinion-to-uphold-high-court-ruling-promote-gender-equality-in-malaysia>.